piclist 2001\01\11\055831a >
Thread: "a/an" in English
picon face BY : Russell McMahon email (remove spam text)

>I wonder about this one.  We would say, "I just finished a history lesson,
>it was an historic occasion.  It was about a historic meeting between two
>I wonder if there are other H words which do weird things.  It may be that
>historic lets the word after it choose the a/an...  It could have
>something to do with being the subject/adjective, but neither of those fit
>up there.  The last phrase could probably do as well with an an or an a.
>Several online english resources, but I haven't seen a mention of a/an

Haven't been following this thread - what fun you guys are having.

Historic is an exception because it is said differently on purpose! - why is
less obvious.
The clearly proper (someone will disagree :-) ) construct is "a historic
occason" and this almost actually sounds OK and some people WOULD say it
that way. It's said "an historic... " because it has become practice to say
it that way.

Another such example is "hotel".
Properly this should be a hotel but in actual \use once says "an hotel".

   "We all went to an hotel for a gin and tonic".

This screams of wrongness but is technically how it should be said.

Possibly because the h is somewhat silent - not quite 'otel but not a full h
always either.

     Russell McMahon

What can one man* do?
Donate food daily free !!! -  http://www.thehungersite.com/
Donate Vitamin A!  http://www.thechildsurvivalsite.com/
http://www.rawa.com  - one perspective on Afghanistan
http://www.changingourworld.com    http://www.easttimor.com   http://www.sudan.com

(* - or woman, child or internet enabled intelligent entity :-))

http://www.piclist.com hint: To leave the PICList

<012601c07bbd$e5094800$0100a8c0@mkbs> 7bit

See also: www.piclist.com/techref/index.htm?key=aan+english
Reply You must be a member of the piclist mailing list (not only a www.piclist.com member) to post to the piclist. This form requires JavaScript and a browser/email client that can handle form mailto: posts.
Subject (change) "a/an" in English

month overview.

new search...