Truncated match.
PICList
Thread
'Price on the totally cold 16F877?'
1999\06\06@233935
by
Tjaart van der Walt
Byron A Jeff wrote:
>
> I'm perusing the datasheet now and I'm definitely in love. How much are these
> parts going for. I think I need to buy a tube.
>
> Also I still can't find any reference to the part on Digikey's web site despit
e
> reports here that Digikey has them. Do I need to call them?
>
> Thanks for any info.
The pricing on the 16$877 is double that of the
ATMEL AVR 90LS8535, which has more goodies in it.
--
Friendly Regards /"\
\ /
Tjaart van der Walt X ASCII RIBBON CAMPAIGN
spam_OUTtjaartTakeThisOuT
wasp.co.za / \ AGAINST HTML MAIL
|--------------------------------------------------|
| Cellpoint Systems SA http://www.cellpt.com |
|--------------------------------------------------|
| http://www.wasp.co.za/~tjaart/index.html |
| WGS84 : -26.0124 +28.1129 |
| Voice : +27 (0)11 2545100 |
|--------------------------------------------------|
1999\06\07@080604
by
Byron A Jeff
>
> Byron A Jeff wrote:
> >
> > I'm perusing the datasheet now and I'm definitely in love. How much are thes
e
> > parts going for. I think I need to buy a tube.
> >
> > Also I still can't find any reference to the part on Digikey's web site desp
ite
> > reports here that Digikey has them. Do I need to call them?
> >
> > Thanks for any info.
>
> The pricing on the 16$877 is double that of the
> ATMEL AVR 90LS8535, which has more goodies in it.
Not helpful Tjaart, but I'll bite.
I'm a Linux guy and I only use Linux for my development. Does Atmel or anyone
else have a Linux/Unix based assembler,simulator and programmer for the
90LS8535?
I can use gpasm for program the 877, I already have a high voltage 16C84
pic programm to program it and the software to drive the programmer. gpsim
has come along nicely.
The software I'm using is already written in PIC assembly.
I'm not buying production quantites so even at double the price it's well
worth my investment.
Actually this is helpful. You said that the Atmel part is $5.90. So at double
the price we're talking about $12 or so. That helps. Thanks.
BAJ
1999\06\07@095533
by
Byron A Jeff
-
- >
- > Byron A Jeff wrote:
- > >
- > > I'm perusing the datasheet now and I'm definitely in love. How much are th
ese
- > > parts going for. I think I need to buy a tube.
- > >
- > > Also I still can't find any reference to the part on Digikey's web site de
spite
- > > reports here that Digikey has them. Do I need to call them?
- > >
- > > Thanks for any info.
- >
- > The pricing on the 16$877 is double that of the
- > ATMEL AVR 90LS8535, which has more goodies in it.
-
- Not helpful Tjaart, but I'll bite.
-
- I'm a Linux guy and I only use Linux for my development. Does Atmel or anyone
- else have a Linux/Unix based assembler,simulator and programmer for the
- 90LS8535?
-
- I can use gpasm for program the 877, I already have a high voltage 16C84
- pic programm to program it and the software to drive the programmer. gpsim
- has come along nicely.
-
- The software I'm using is already written in PIC assembly.
-
- I'm not buying production quantites so even at double the price it's well
- worth my investment.
-
- Actually this is helpful. You said that the Atmel part is $5.90. So at double
- the price we're talking about $12 or so. That helps. Thanks.
And an addendum. Where can you get Atmel parts. As a hobbiest it's tough
making relationships with distributors who really only want to talk to you if
you're planning on buying a half million pieces. So Generally I stick to
hobbiest friendly places: Digikey, BGMicro, Jameco, Marshall and DallasSemi's
small order lines. I'll go out on a limb to Future or Arrow if the part
warrants it.
Digikey has full integration of Microchip. I haven't seen Atmel there or
anywhere else I frequent.
I saw somewhere that for almost any product that there's a 10X price spread
between the low end and high end of the product. IIRC the example was that one
could buy a $30 kitchen faucet or a $300 kitchen faucet. The issue between the
two are style, material, craftsmanship, etc.
It's the same here. Microchip has worked damn hard to cultivate its PIC line.
They have been open and hobbiest friendly from the beginning. PIC is a brand
name and a pretty good one at that.
My grandfather only bought Zenith TV's. They were always more expensive, but
that's what he trusted. That's how I feel about PICs. So unless there is
an extremely compelling reason to switch, I probably won't. And even at $15
a pop, the 16C877 is a godsend.
I've learned from experience that standardizing even at a higher average cost
saves time and aggravation in the long run. So AMD based PCs are my computing
hardware platform, Linux is my OS, and PIC's are my microcontroller.
BAJ
1999\06\07@100609
by
jamesp
|
What he said........
>-
>- >
>- > Byron A Jeff wrote:
>- > >
>- > > I'm perusing the datasheet now and I'm definitely in love. How much are
these
>- > > parts going for. I think I need to buy a tube.
>- > >
>- > > Also I still can't find any reference to the part on Digikey's web site
despite
{Quote hidden}>- > > reports here that Digikey has them. Do I need to call them?
>- > >
>- > > Thanks for any info.
>- >
>- > The pricing on the 16$877 is double that of the
>- > ATMEL AVR 90LS8535, which has more goodies in it.
>-
>- Not helpful Tjaart, but I'll bite.
>-
>- I'm a Linux guy and I only use Linux for my development. Does Atmel or anyone
>- else have a Linux/Unix based assembler,simulator and programmer for the
>- 90LS8535?
>-
>- I can use gpasm for program the 877, I already have a high voltage 16C84
>- pic programm to program it and the software to drive the programmer. gpsim
>- has come along nicely.
>-
>- The software I'm using is already written in PIC assembly.
>-
>- I'm not buying production quantites so even at double the price it's well
>- worth my investment.
>-
>- Actually this is helpful. You said that the Atmel part is $5.90. So at double
>- the price we're talking about $12 or so. That helps. Thanks.
>
>And an addendum. Where can you get Atmel parts. As a hobbiest it's tough
>making relationships with distributors who really only want to talk to you
if
{Quote hidden}>you're planning on buying a half million pieces. So Generally I stick to
>hobbiest friendly places: Digikey, BGMicro, Jameco, Marshall and DallasSemi's
>small order lines. I'll go out on a limb to Future or Arrow if the part
>warrants it.
>
>Digikey has full integration of Microchip. I haven't seen Atmel there or
>anywhere else I frequent.
>
>I saw somewhere that for almost any product that there's a 10X price spread
>between the low end and high end of the product. IIRC the example was that
one
>could buy a $30 kitchen faucet or a $300 kitchen faucet. The issue between
the
{Quote hidden}>two are style, material, craftsmanship, etc.
>
>It's the same here. Microchip has worked damn hard to cultivate its PIC line.
>They have been open and hobbiest friendly from the beginning. PIC is a brand
>name and a pretty good one at that.
>
>My grandfather only bought Zenith TV's. They were always more expensive, but
>that's what he trusted. That's how I feel about PICs. So unless there is
>an extremely compelling reason to switch, I probably won't. And even at $15
>a pop, the 16C877 is a godsend.
>
>I've learned from experience that standardizing even at a higher average cost
>saves time and aggravation in the long run. So AMD based PCs are my computing
>hardware platform, Linux is my OS, and PIC's are my microcontroller.
>
>BAJ
>
1999\06\07@112238
by
Andy Kunz
>an extremely compelling reason to switch, I probably won't. And even at $15
>a pop, the 16C877 is a godsend.
Wow, glad I'm buying them in quantity! I get them under $10.
Andy
==================================================================
INTRODUCTORY PRICING ENDS JULY 1, 1999
==================================================================
Andy Kunz Life is what we do to prepare for Eternity
------------------------------------------------------------------
.....andyKILLspam
@spam@rc-hydros.com http://www.rc-hydros.com - Race Boats
andy
KILLspammontanadesign.com http://www.montanadesign.com - Electronics
==================================================================
1999\06\07@121422
by
Byron A Jeff
>
> >an extremely compelling reason to switch, I probably won't. And even at $15
> >a pop, the 16C877 is a godsend.
>
> Wow, glad I'm buying them in quantity! I get them under $10.
Where? How?
BAJ
1999\06\07@122911
by
Stefan Sczekalla-Waldschmidt
|
Byron A Jeff wrote:
>
> -
> - >
> - > Byron A Jeff wrote:
> - > >
> - > > I'm perusing the datasheet now and I'm definitely in love. How much are
these
> - > > parts going for. I think I need to buy a tube.
> - > >
> - > > Also I still can't find any reference to the part on Digikey's web site
despite
{Quote hidden}> - > > reports here that Digikey has them. Do I need to call them?
> - > >
> - > > Thanks for any info.
> - >
> - > The pricing on the 16$877 is double that of the
> - > ATMEL AVR 90LS8535, which has more goodies in it.
> -
> - Not helpful Tjaart, but I'll bite.
> -
> - I'm a Linux guy and I only use Linux for my development. Does Atmel or anyon
e
> - else have a Linux/Unix based assembler,simulator and programmer for the
> - 90LS8535?
> -
> - I can use gpasm for program the 877, I already have a high voltage 16C84
> - pic programm to program it and the software to drive the programmer. gpsim
> - has come along nicely.
> -
> - The software I'm using is already written in PIC assembly.
> -
> - I'm not buying production quantites so even at double the price it's well
> - worth my investment.
> -
> - Actually this is helpful. You said that the Atmel part is $5.90. So at doubl
e
> - the price we're talking about $12 or so. That helps. Thanks.
>
> And an addendum. Where can you get Atmel parts.
Conrad Electronic (http://www.conrad.de)
Have the whole available Family, I ordered some 90S4433 today,
price approx 9 Euro incl 16% local Tax .
{Quote hidden}> As a hobbiest it's tough
> making relationships with distributors who really only want to talk to you if
> you're planning on buying a half million pieces. So Generally I stick to
> hobbiest friendly places: Digikey, BGMicro, Jameco, Marshall and DallasSemi's
> small order lines. I'll go out on a limb to Future or Arrow if the part
> warrants it.
>
> Digikey has full integration of Microchip. I haven't seen Atmel there or
> anywhere else I frequent.
>
> I saw somewhere that for almost any product that there's a 10X price spread
> between the low end and high end of the product. IIRC the example was that one
> could buy a $30 kitchen faucet or a $300 kitchen faucet. The issue between the
> two are style, material, craftsmanship, etc.
>
> It's the same here. Microchip has worked damn hard to cultivate its PIC line.
> They have been open and hobbiest friendly from the beginning. PIC is a brand
> name and a pretty good one at that.
>
> My grandfather only bought Zenith TV's. They were always more expensive, but
> that's what he trusted. That's how I feel about PICs. So unless there is
> an extremely compelling reason to switch, I probably won't. And even at $15
> a pop, the 16C877 is a godsend.
>
> I've learned from experience that standardizing even at a higher average cost
> saves time and aggravation in the long run. So AMD based PCs are my computing
> hardware platform, Linux is my OS, and PIC's are my microcontroller.
>
> BAJ
1999\06\07@181956
by
Andy Kunz
>> Wow, glad I'm buying them in quantity! I get them under $10.
>
>Where? How?
FAI/Future. Volume.
POint: Don't let onesies prices scare you off.
Andy
==================================================================
INTRODUCTORY PRICING ENDS JULY 1, 1999
==================================================================
Andy Kunz Life is what we do to prepare for Eternity
------------------------------------------------------------------
.....andyKILLspam
.....rc-hydros.com http://www.rc-hydros.com - Race Boats
EraseMEandyspam_OUT
TakeThisOuTmontanadesign.com http://www.montanadesign.com - Electronics
==================================================================
1999\06\07@202132
by
Byron A Jeff
>
> >> Wow, glad I'm buying them in quantity! I get them under $10.
> >
> >Where? How?
>
> FAI/Future. Volume.
>
> POint: Don't let onesies prices scare you off.
It didn't. What scared me off was that I couldn't get a onsie or a twosie.
Future only wanted to sell tensies!
BTW Digikey has them. Part number is PIC16F877-20/P. Both the web site and
the phone folks can find the part under that number. I ordered to for $14.25
each. I consider it a great savings over having to pay $142.10 for Future's
"volume" price.
BAJ
1999\06\07@222226
by
ShadeDemon
Andy Kunz wrote:
> >> Wow, glad I'm buying them in quantity! I get them under $10.
> FAI/Future. Volume.
> POint: Don't let onesies prices scare you off.
And at 25 it comes down to a pretty reasonable 8.60 each
for $215 total. If they'd just make it hit that point at 10
I think they could sell more blocks of ten than individual
chips.
Alan
1999\06\08@004113
by
Tjaart van der Walt
|
Byron A Jeff wrote:
>
> And an addendum. Where can you get Atmel parts. As a hobbiest it's tough
> making relationships with distributors who really only want to talk to you if
> you're planning on buying a half million pieces. So Generally I stick to
> hobbiest friendly places: Digikey, BGMicro, Jameco, Marshall and DallasSemi's
> small order lines. I'll go out on a limb to Future or Arrow if the part
> warrants it.
We can get it from a few suppliers in South Africa. You can try
Arrow or Avnet.
> I've learned from experience that standardizing even at a higher average cost
> saves time and aggravation in the long run. So AMD based PCs are my computing
> hardware platform, Linux is my OS, and PIC's are my microcontroller.
I agree. Check out the migration path between AVR's.
No banking means no migration headaches. Have you had
a look at the Mega AVR? It is an awesome beast with 4X
the memory of the biggest PIC and a series of other bells
& whistles. It is also flash (of course), and cheaper than
the 17$7XX OTP PICs.
Where Mchip is hammering on the internal EEPROM as a sales
pitch (on some PICs), it is standard on the ATMELs. If you
are sick of using precious internal (OTP) ROM for I2C
libraries, you can get by much better with the internal EEPROM
in the AVR's. In fact, the 90LS8535 (equivalent of the 16$877)
has the equivalent of a 24C04 (512 bytes) of EEPROM built-in.
--
Friendly Regards /"\
\ /
Tjaart van der Walt X ASCII RIBBON CAMPAIGN
tjaart
spam_OUTwasp.co.za / \ AGAINST HTML MAIL
|--------------------------------------------------|
| Cellpoint Systems SA http://www.cellpt.com |
|--------------------------------------------------|
| http://www.wasp.co.za/~tjaart/index.html |
| WGS84 : -26.0124 +28.1129 |
| Voice : +27 (0)11 2545100 |
|--------------------------------------------------|
1999\06\08@005259
by
Eric Smith
> > FAI/Future. Volume.
> > POint: Don't let onesies prices scare you off.
> And at 25 it comes down to a pretty reasonable 8.60 each
> for $215 total. If they'd just make it hit that point at 10
> I think they could sell more blocks of ten than individual
> chips.
You're assuming that they *want* to sell them in lots of ten. They
don't. It costs them more to deal with small orders, and they pass
those costs on to you.
1999\06\08@150305
by
Byron A Jeff
>
> Byron A Jeff wrote:
> >
> > And an addendum. Where can you get Atmel parts. As a hobbiest it's tough
> > making relationships with distributors who really only want to talk to you i
f
> > you're planning on buying a half million pieces. So Generally I stick to
> > hobbiest friendly places: Digikey, BGMicro, Jameco, Marshall and DallasSemi'
s
> > small order lines. I'll go out on a limb to Future or Arrow if the part
> > warrants it.
>
> We can get it from a few suppliers in South Africa. You can try
> Arrow or Avnet.
Marshall Small Order sales has them too.
{Quote hidden}>
> > I've learned from experience that standardizing even at a higher average cos
t
> > saves time and aggravation in the long run. So AMD based PCs are my computin
g
> > hardware platform, Linux is my OS, and PIC's are my microcontroller.
> I agree. Check out the migration path between AVR's.
>
> No banking means no migration headaches. Have you had
> a look at the Mega AVR? It is an awesome beast with 4X
> the memory of the biggest PIC and a series of other bells
> & whistles. It is also flash (of course), and cheaper than
> the 17$7XX OTP PICs.
But it's overkill for the types of applications I use PICs for. At this point
in time I really don't think I have a need for any 17X parts.
>
> Where Mchip is hammering on the internal EEPROM as a sales
> pitch (on some PICs), it is standard on the ATMELs. If you
> are sick of using precious internal (OTP) ROM for I2C
> libraries, you can get by much better with the internal EEPROM
> in the AVR's. In fact, the 90LS8535 (equivalent of the 16$877)
> has the equivalent of a 24C04 (512 bytes) of EEPROM built-in.
But you still haven't answered my original assertion which has been cut from
this message: Where can I find equivalent tools for Linux that I already
have for the PIC. When the environment exists for one, and doesn't exist for
the other, minor differences in cost aren't relavent.
As to why Linux, it's my choice. I realize that means that I'm shut out of
a lot of environments, but I can live with that.
Your points are relavent if you are buying several thousand parts. Costs are
the critical issue. But for a hobbiest like myself that's going to one-off
projects, comfort with both the part and the development environment are key.
BTW I use external EEPROMS because I get the ability to program in-circuit
without have to deal with the overhead of building a full-fledged programmer
for the controller in-circuit.
Lastly the 16$877 as you call it has an excellent I2C interface so minimal
library code is necessary for setup and xmission.
You haven't brought anything compelling to the table yet Tjaart. Even at 2.5X
the price ($5.90 for 90LS8535 compared to $14.25 for the 16F877 in single
quantities) there's no compelling reason to switch. I know that the minute
I get the 16F877 parts, I'll have a high level language, assembler, programmer,
and many years of PIC experience backing the part up. With the Atmel part
I have very little to start from. I'll have to build a programmer, get a
new assembler, not have a HLL environment, and I'd have to switch to Windows
to use the software that's available for the part. And trust me that isn't
nearly worth the $8.35 a part in savings or the minor issues of bank switching
which my token environment doesn't have because it does everything via
indirect references.
Microchip has done it's job. It has me pretty much locked in and moving
somewhere else, while not impossible, is extremely difficult. Call it a
guilded cage.
BAJ
1999\06\09@010710
by
Tjaart van der Walt
|
Byron A Jeff wrote:
>
> >
> > Where Mchip is hammering on the internal EEPROM as a sales
> > pitch (on some PICs), it is standard on the ATMELs. If you
> > are sick of using precious internal (OTP) ROM for I2C
> > libraries, you can get by much better with the internal EEPROM
> > in the AVR's. In fact, the 90LS8535 (equivalent of the 16$877)
> > has the equivalent of a 24C04 (512 bytes) of EEPROM built-in.
>
> But you still haven't answered my original assertion which has been cut from
> this message: Where can I find equivalent tools for Linux that I already
> have for the PIC. When the environment exists for one, and doesn't exist for
> the other, minor differences in cost aren't relavent.
You are right - I left that for the folks who use
Linux for the development environment.
{Quote hidden}> As to why Linux, it's my choice. I realize that means that I'm shut out of
> a lot of environments, but I can live with that.
>
> Your points are relavent if you are buying several thousand parts. Costs are
> the critical issue. But for a hobbiest like myself that's going to one-off
> projects, comfort with both the part and the development environment are key.
>
> BTW I use external EEPROMS because I get the ability to program in-circuit
> without have to deal with the overhead of building a full-fledged programmer
> for the controller in-circuit.
>
> Lastly the 16$877 as you call it has an excellent I2C interface so minimal
> library code is necessary for setup and xmission.
I've used the '74 and the '77 for a good while with I2C. It
is more schlep to set up and massage the I2C hardware than
what it is to just bit-bang it (for me anyway).
> You haven't brought anything compelling to the table yet Tjaart. Even at 2.5X
> the price ($5.90 for 90LS8535 compared to $14.25 for the 16F877 in single
> quantities) there's no compelling reason to switch. I know that the minute
Do you want it free then? ;)
<snip>
> Microchip has done it's job. It has me pretty much locked in and moving
> somewhere else, while not impossible, is extremely difficult. Call it a
> guilded cage.
Same problem here.
--
Friendly Regards /"\
\ /
Tjaart van der Walt X ASCII RIBBON CAMPAIGN
@spam@tjaartKILLspam
wasp.co.za / \ AGAINST HTML MAIL
|--------------------------------------------------|
| Cellpoint Systems SA http://www.cellpt.com |
|--------------------------------------------------|
| http://www.wasp.co.za/~tjaart/index.html |
| WGS84 : -26.0124 +28.1129 |
| Voice : +27 (0)11 2545100 |
|--------------------------------------------------|
More... (looser matching)
- Last day of these posts
- In 1999
, 2000 only
- Today
- New search...