No exact or substring matches. trying for part
'[PICLIST] Recommendation of uC, which is better?'
I need some recommendation on the type of PIC that i
could use. Please read on.
I have wrote some assembly for 68HC11 and studied
on the architecture of Motorolla 68K. I find both of
them complicated, which is why i choose pic16F84 to
use in my final year project. and i never regreted my
Now i am in the new job and the previous engineer in
company uses Motorolla uC(and he is very good at it).
I need to justify my choice of microcontroller by
1. i can produce a solution in a similar or shorter
2. i don't need expensive programmer and emulator
3. the uC/uP are cheaper than Mot. for a comparable
speed, memory and function ( like A/D convt. )
i don't mind building my own programmer or even
emulator if these info are available freely. Do any
PICListers think this is possible? or maybe possible
up to a certain extent?
Obviously i need a faster uC ( > 20MHz ), larger
memory, and more i/o pins. i would want to use this uC
in most of my solution except when the solution needed
me to have built in modules like the Ethernet module
( Motorolla Coldfire ).
I hope everyone would give me their evaluation, the
final recommendation may not necessary be pic. Maybe i
should stick to Motorolla, or Scenix ? What constitute
a good engineer? Expert on many types of uc OR Master
of one or two type of uC? Thanks for any advice given.
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://www.piclist.com#nomail Going offline? Don't AutoReply us!
email mitvma.mit.edu with SET PICList DIGEST in the body listserv
|> i don't mind building my own programmer or even
> emulator if these info are available freely. Do any
> PICListers think this is possible? or maybe possible
> up to a certain extent?
I have an emulator for PICs somewhere in a closet. I haven't used it in
years. I have two programmers - a PICstart Plus (<$200US) for
out-of-socket programming and a EPIC (from Microengineering Labs <$100US)
for In-System Programming. The EPIC could do both jobs. Just buy one, and
skip the emulator, don't build either. Definitely under $200US and you are
programming PICs. Assembly language compiler is free from MicroChip.
I find that making the PIC tell me what is going on, via a serial
connection, is just as valuable as an emulator. While I'm developing I add
in some check points, and print them out a serial LCD, like
if(some dumb error happens)
printf("You Bozo! You did it again!");
and that is the only troubleshooting tool I really need.
If you are doing anything high end you'll also need a C compiler, a
discussion which will ignite a religious war here on the PIClist.
http://www.htsoft.com and http://www.ccsinfo.com/picc.html are the two major
players, $100 to $800 US depending on options etc. Microchip also has one
that only works for some of their parts.
> Obviously i need a faster uC ( > 20MHz ), larger
> memory, and more i/o pins. i would want to use this uC
> in most of my solution except when the solution needed
> me to have built in modules like the Ethernet module
> ( Motorolla Coldfire ).
You may need more horsepower than the fastest PIC. In that case, we're
knocked out. I don't think there is any PIC that could handle an ethernet
connection, or has that as a built-in module. Most top out at 20MHz.
> a good engineer? Expert on many types of uc OR Master
> of one or two type of uC? Thanks for any advice given.
I would go for the breadth. The more architectures and technologies you are
familiar with, the more versatile you are. Learn a little about them all,
and on your next job, when they ask you if you know anything about X you can
-- Lawrence Lile
http://www.piclist.com hint: To leave the PICList
More... (looser matching)
- Last day of these posts
- In 2001
, 2002 only
- New search...